Showing posts with label Biochemistry. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Biochemistry. Show all posts

Wednesday, 16 September 2009

RNA interference - Part 2: regulation of gene expression

(This post follows Part 1.)

Assuming that the microRNA-Dicer-RISC algorithm (usually collectively known as RNA interference) did initially evolve as a defence against viruses*, it might seem odd that this isn't its chief function today. Rather, RNA interference predominantly earns its keep by downregulating the expression of various genes.

Assuming that the dicer-RISC sequence is already operational, how could you use it to modify gene expression of your own, normal genes? Hint: RNA interference only acts after the relevant gene has been transcribed into RNA (as its name suggests!), so we'll have to concentrate our efforts there.

Any guesses? Well, what we could do is simply synthesise a short bit of RNA that is complementary to a part of the transcribed RNA sequence. That way, it would automatically bind to the target gene's RNA and form ... double-stranded DNA. And, as we've shown in the previous post, the presence of double-stranded DNA provokes an alarm response in the cell ("perhaps it's a virus!") that rapidly degrades it, and any copies of it (single stranded or double-stranded), by the Dicer-RISC mechanism of RNA interference.

As so happens, that is exactly what occurs. Hundreds of our own genes encode small fragments of RNA complementary to other genes; these fragments are called microRNA (miRNA). And if these fragments bind to their counterpart RNA, the RNA interference mechanism is activated. In all there are at least 500 miRNAs present in mammalian cells, collectively down-regulating 30% of our genes.

Appropriately enough for such a new discovery, that isn't the end of the RNA interference story. For instance, it has also been implicated in keeping chromatin condensed, and in preventing transcription (in addition to translation). But that's enough for now...



* This is quite a big assumption, actually - the jury's still out.

Tuesday, 15 September 2009

RNA interference - Part 1: an ancient antiviral

As every textbook attests, three types of RNA have long been identified: messenger RNA (mRNA), transfer RNA (tRNA) and ribosomal RNA (rRNA). However, the past decade and a half hasn't been kind to this convenient list. Several other kinds of RNA have now demanded inclusion, and foremost among them is probably microRNA (miRNA) and small interfering RNA (siRNA). The latter two are both intimately involved in the phenomenon known as RNA interference.

The evolutionary origin of RNA interference is obscure, but I favour (if only for explanatory reasons) one theory in particular, namely that it is an ancient defence against viruses that has been adapted to meet other additional demands. Let me explain.

Although all 'higher' lifeforms exclusively use DNA to store their genomes, viruses can use either DNA or RNA (or sometimes both!). In fact, most use RNA, in either a single- or a double-stranded form. The hardest part of fighting viruses is to find them - they are fundamentally just nucleic acid surrounded by a protein coat. The protein coat is usually their weakness, as it is something decidedly foreign that the immune system can recognise and attack. However, if a virus should inject its nucleic acid into a cell, the cell has almost no way to recognise the RNA or DNA as foreign - why would it? RNA is RNA!

Usually what has to happen is that a selection of the virus' (foreign) proteins are displayed by the routine sampling process common to almost all cells - the protein fragments are attached to the MHC class I molecule, which strongly interacts with surveillance cells of the immune system. If a "non-self" molecule is detected, the immune cell will politely ask its infected counterpart to self-destruct (apoptosis) or, failing that, simply destroy the cell itself. (Viruses which disable the MHC I sampling process are dealt with by natural killer cells, as explained here.)

This method usually works well enough (or we'd all be dead), but it is frustratingly indirect - a cell has to be long on the road to helping the virus replicate before it can be stopped. Is there any hope at all of identifying viral RNA before it does its damage? Well, although RNA is RNA is RNA (etc.) there is one form of viral RNA that can be reliably distinguished from our own native RNA - double-stranded RNA, which is never normally produced by our cells.

Just as you'd expect, our cells can not only recognise but also actively destroy any hint of double-stranded RNA (ds-RNA). A protein with the wonderful name of Dicer lives up to its name by slicing any identified ds-RNA into useless fragments, thereby preventing the RNA from being translated into a protein. Each of these RNA fragments is very small, by RNA standards, and they are collectively referred to as small interfering RNAs (siRNA).

Furthermore, the process is vindictive. Once the ds-RNA has been cleaved, the bits bind a protein complex, called RISC, which stands for RNA-induced silencing complex. One of the two RNA strands is eliminated, but the other, still bound to RISC, acts as bait for other copies of the RNA molecule, attaching to them by the familiar base pairing rules common to all life (A to T, C to G). If this occurs, RISC cuts the newly-bound mRNA strand, but retains the other fragment in order to sleuth out more of these foreign RNA molecules.

In this way, a cell may be purged of viral RNA. But this is only the tip of the proverbial iceberg when it comes to the power of microRNA, and it wasn't at all how miRNA was discovered. We'll cover that in the next post.

Saturday, 9 May 2009

The Central Dogma of Molecular Biology

I thought I'd venture just a little outside of medicine today.  After his co-discovery of the structure of DNA in 1953, Francis Crick's next keen interest was in elucidating how the DNA-RNA-protein sequence unfolded.  At that stage, it was still unclear as to which of the 9 'transformations' were possible.  For instance, could DNA transfer its information to RNA directly, or did it have to go through the intermediate of a protein? Could a cell subsist on RNA alone (without DNA)?  Could proteins generate DNA?  Could you create RNA from other RNA, and could you make DNA from an RNA template?  The nine possibilities for information transfer between each of the three actors had varying degrees of experimental backing, but little in the way of theoretical guidance.  In Crick's own words:

All we had to work on were certain fragmentary experimental results, themselves often rather uncertain and confused, and a boundless optimism that the basic concepts involved were rather simple and probably much the same in living things.  In such a situation well constructed theories can play a really useful part in stating problems clearly and thus guiding experiment. 

With roughly that desire in mind, Crick famously argued in 1958 that the 9 possible transformations could be divided into three groups.

The first group consisted of those for which there was positive evidence.  At the time, this was limited to:
  • DNA → DNA
  • DNA → RNA
  • RNA → Protein
  • RNA → RNA
The second group dealt with those transfers for which there lacked any evidence or theoretical requirement, but which were nonetheless felt to be be plausible, even if they turned out to be rare or absent from the world.  These were:
  • RNA → DNA
  • DNA → Protein
The last group were felt, on theoretical reasons (rather than on lack of experimental support), to be extremely unlikely to occur.  They were:
  • Protein → Protein
  • Protein → RNA
  • Protein → DNA
As you can see, Crick was very skeptical of the idea that information could be transferred from a protein to anything else. (Briefly, he thought that the complicated machinery for translating the DNA/RNA 'alphabet' into a completely different amino acid 'alphabet' couldn't work backwards, and there was no evidence of any alternative complicated machinery to perform this back-translation.) Proteins were thus dead ends for information, and this insight constituted his 'Central Dogma of Molecular Biology': "once (sequential) information has passed into protein it cannot get out again."

Just as Crick had hoped, this insight proved to be both valid and enormously useful.  Incidentally, the first of the second group's constituents has now found experimental support, largely in the form of the retroviruses (like HIV), which initially use their own RNA to back-translate their information into DNA.  Will we one day discover a "DNA → Protein" transformation?

Crick wrote an extremely accessible defense of his Central Dogma in the journal Nature in 1970. You can access the PDF by clicking here; I strongly recommend it for its wonderful clarity and its knack of hitting nails on heads.  It's superb.

Monday, 27 April 2009

Which hormones does the adrenal medulla secrete?

The adrenal gland is anatomically divided into the cortex and medullary regions, and for once this division is actually important.  So different are the two areas that they might as well be separate organs.  

The adrenal medulla secretes only catecholamines - adrenaline (epinephrine*), noradrenaline (norepinephrine) and dopamine.  Of these three hormones, adrenaline makes up the lion's share of the catecholamine output here - about 80%, to be specific.

Unusually for an endocrine organ, the secretion of these hormones is regulated by direct nervous innervation to the gland.  Preganglionic sympathetic nerves secrete acetylcholine, and this causes the adrenal medulla to secrete its catecholamine load.

In many ways, it is best to conceive of the adrenal medulla a giant sympathetic ganglion, capable of rapidly boosting the sympathetic nervous system's response to a "fight or flight" situation.  As you know, one of the autonomic nervous system's characteristics is that it has two effector neurones instead of one.  The preganglionic neurone, originating in the brain stem or spinal cord, synapses with the postganglionic neurone at a ganglion.  The former secretes acetylcholine, and, in the case of the sympathetic nervous system, the latter usually secretes noradrenaline (norepinephrine).  This is a local response: the amount of adrenaline secreted by the postganglionic neurone is so small that it only affects those few cells in the immediate vicinity. 

In the case of the adrenal medulla, the mechanism is the same ('preganglionic' acetylcholine secretion, catecholamine response), but instead of a postganglionic neurone, the very cells of the medulla produce catecholamines directly.  This is why I say that the it can be thought of as a sympathetic ganglion that produces its own catecholamines directly, without needing a second neurone. 

The reason for this modification of the usual sympathetic nervous systemic pattern is so that the medulla can quickly and directly generate huge amounts of catecholamine for the systemic circulation (another neurone in the pathway would only slow things down).  As a consequence of all this, the whole body can rapidly respond to a sympathetic signal without each cell having to be stimulated individually.

*See here for the epinephrine vs adrenaline story.

Monday, 13 April 2009

Fat as an energy reserve

Why, when we eat a meal containing more calories than we presently need, is most of the excess substance stored as fat?  To be sure, we do also stores of both carbohydrate and protein, but the carbohydrate stores are pretty small (about 2500 kJ of glycogen), and the body prefers not to tap the 100 000 kJ of protein significantly, since it largely comes from our muscles.  By contrast, a fairly lean 70 kg man has reserves of about 400 000 kJ in total body fat.  Clearly, therefore, the body expresses a strong preference for storing excess energy as fat.  Why?

Simply put, fat is the most concentrated form in which to store energy.  There are two reasons for this.  Firstly, the body can get more energy per gram of fat than it can with similar carbohydrates or proteins.  The complete oxidation of triglycerides yields 37 kJ/g or more (depending on the type of triglyceride), compared with about 17 kJ/g for both carbohydrates and proteins.  (More energy can be plundered from fats because the relevant carbons are in a more reduced state; oxidation therefore releases correspondingly more energy.) 

Furthermore, fat isn't hydrophilic.  This may sound irrelevant, but glycogen's hydrophilic nature means that it binds about 2 grams of water for each of its own grams.  Fat, on the other hand, eschews water and this allows it to be stored more efficiently - when it comes to packaging, water doesn't have to tag along.   

Put together, the fact that fat is more highly reduced and is also anhydrous means that fat contains about 6 times as much energy per gram than carbohydrates do.  That's why it's a clear favourite of the body's when it comes to storing energy.

Reference: Biochemistry (3rd edn.), Mathews, van Holde, Ahern

Saturday, 11 April 2009

The crazy naming of the vitamins

The first time I learned about vitamins, their nomenclature struck me as distinctly odd, to say the least.  First off you had vitamin A, which seemed like a sensible-enough place to start, and this was happily followed by vitamins B, C, D and E.  But then an odd thing happened: instead of simply calling the next vitamin "F", some odd individual(s) had moved right along to "K"!  To make matters worse, I then learnt that vitamin B wasn't a vitamin at all, but the collective name for no less than eight distinct compounds, each a vitamin in its own right.  The lunacy didn't stop their either; the B vitamins were numbered 1, 2, 3, 5, 6, 7, 9, and 12! I know that mad scientists aren't always a cliche, but even by their standards something bizarre was going on here.  What the hell was it?

Well, the "K" part comes from the fact that its discovery was published in a German science journal.  Noting that vitamin K had been shown to be intimately involved with the normal coagulation cascade, the journal referred to it (in German) as "Koagulations-Vitamin", and the "K" stuck.  Not that's it's any excuse, but that's the story.

Just why there are so many different B vitamins has a slightly more rational explanation.  Initially, the substances collectively referred to as the vitamin B complex were thought to be a single compound.  This was far from a careless oversight - chemical identification methods were constrained by the technology of the day, and all B vitamins do all share similar chemical characteristics (like their solubility in water), as well as often being found in the same sources.  As successive, more advanced, tests were undertaken, it soon became apparent that there wasn't just one B vitamin.  Furthermore,  some of the compounds initially assumed to be part of the B vitamin complex were later discovered to not be vitamins at all, at least not in humans.  Their removal left the gaps in the B vitamin numbers, but the remaining compounds have their scientific ancestory stamped onto their names with the letter "B".  

The craziness of the vitamin's names is a case study in scientific inertia.  Once something has a name attached to it, it is evidently quite hard to convince enough people to rename it, even if the new name makes much more sense.

Friday, 12 December 2008

How does a vitamin B6 deficiency give you a peripheral neuropathy?

There are at least three closely related compounds that can lay claim to being called vitamin B6, but the most memorable of them (since this is the form we usually administer) is pyridoxine. A deficiency of this vitamin is well known to cause a peripheral neuropathy.

Just why this occurs is made clear when we understand what vitamin B6 usually does. Under normal conditions, the vitamin acts as a cofactor in the synthesis of several neurotransmitters: adrenaline, noradrenaline, serotonin and levodopa to be precise. Clearly, if the production of neurotransmitters is impaired, it isn't that difficult to see why a dysfunction of nervous tissue might result. The reason the peripheral nerves are the most frequently involved is simply because they are the longest, and thus the susceptible to any perturbation. (In almost all cases of peripheral neuropathy, the damage to nerves in the body is pretty general, and it is only because the peripheral ones are the biggest targets that they are most affected.)

Although a dietary deficiency of vitamin B6 is fairly uncommon in the over-nourished Western world, symptoms of this vitamin's deficiency come to the fore when using certain drugs. In particular, isoniazid (a first-line anti-tuberculous drug) not uncommonly causes a peripheral neuropathy, and it does this by competing with pyridoxine in its action as a cofactor of those neurotransmitters' synthesis. To counter this possibility, patients treated with the drug are often supplemented with pyridoxine, especially if they have other risk factors for peripheral neuropathies, such as diabetes and HIV.

Friday, 28 November 2008

How is it possible that most genetic variation occurs between individuals, rather than between races?

When I was in medical school, one rather politically active lecturer reassured us that there was more (total) genetic variation between individuals than there was between people of different races. In think she intended this as an empiric demonstration that racism is inherently illogical.

Of course, her statistic was nonsense, and we can prove it from the comfort of the armchair. Take yourself and one of this planet's other people at random, and let's call the amount of genetic variation between your genomes 'G'. (The amount of genetic variation would correspond to the total number of base pair differences in their genomes.) As it stands, 'G' is only a population average; we can increase or decrease our estimates of it if we find out more information. For instance, say that we discover that the other person is your brother. G would then be much less than average - you and your brother can be expected to show much less genetic variation than two people chosen at random, since you share a very recent set of common ancestors (your parents!).

And what if I told you instead that the other person was of a different race to you? In that case, your estimation (i.e. your best guess) should be that it would increase the value of G. Races aren't physically identical (obviously, otherwise there would be no races), and genes code for these differences. Therefore, although you have a certain probability of sharing any particular gene with someone else on the planet, the genes that code for the racial differences must be different. This is why your estimated value of G goes up. Put another way, it must be true that there is more total genetic variability between races than between individuals.

But there is a kernel of truth to what my lecturer said. She was probably misquoting a very interesting statistic, namely that most of the genetic variability between people is not as a result being of a different race. The 'race genes' are only a small subset of those that differ between people. According to one estimate, only about 7% of genetic differences can be attributed to racial differences, whilst 85% are individual variations (and the rest are ethnic or national differences). And even when all the genetic variation is taken together, as a species we are in fact rather closely related.

Of course, no scientific finding could ever justify racism of any sort. One mustn't make the mistake of mixing up the world of facts with the world of ethics. For instance, let us say that today's findings were overturned, and the evidence clearly showed that the differences between the races were huge. Would it then be alright to enact blanket discrimination against a particular race? Of course not. Ethical principles like equality of opportunity, equality before the law and human kindness don't require a scientist to discover them, and nor can any scientific finding invalidate them.

Monday, 10 November 2008

Can we please all put it to bed now?

I've written a little on the fairly technical subject of thermodynamics, since it does tend to come up at an undergraduate level in medicine. One of the enduring myths about the thermodynamic laws, tirelessly perpetuated by creationists, is that evolution violates them. I've already explained (as have thousands before me) why this is simply a falsehood: simply put, evolution is no more miraculous, from a thermodynamic point of view, than growing a baby from a single cell, or watching snowflakes form. In each of these cases, there is a local decrease in entropy that is allowed because the embryo/snowflake isn't a closed system - it is an open system. (See here for definitions of these terms). And in an open system, entropy can decrease.

Another way to answer the creationist challenge to the second law of thermodynamics is to note that it "does not state that nothing can ever increase in order, but only that an decrease in one part must be accompanied by a greater increase in entropy in another." Enter Daniel Styer, a physicist, who has put some meat on this statement's bones.

Being exceptionally conservative with his estimates, he has calculated that, on earth "there's about a trillion times more entropy flux available than is required for evolution. The degree by which earth's entropy is reduced by the action of evolutionary processes is miniscule [sic] relative to the amount that the entropy of the cosmic microwave background is increased."

In other words, the requirement that evolution's local increase in entropy be paid for by a bigger decrease elsewhere is easy to meet. Really easy. To my knowledge, this is the first paper to bother to estimate actual figures for the topic, which makes it quite useful in debates.

The quotes are from a post over at Pharyngula, to be found here. Go read it, it's excellent.

Friday, 31 October 2008

Is our DNA redundant or degenerate?

If you are using these words as they apply in genetics, then it is both.

An amino acid is specified by a codon of three DNA letters, and there are four choices for each letter slot - namely C, G, A and T. You can think of a codon as a word; in the DNA language words are only made up of three letters.

How many different words can DNA express, theoretically? For each letter there are four options, so the maximum number of words must be 43 = 64.

However, DNA only uses 21 words (or 23, depending on how you count). 20 of these code for amino acids, and there is also a stop codon, which tells the cell's machinery when the protein ends. (Actually, there are 3 stop codons, but these have identical 'meanings' to the cell, and are therefore best counted as one.)

The fact that DNA could accommodate a larger variety of meanings (namely, 64) than it does (namely, 21) means that, in a technical sense, the DNA code is degenerate.

The redundancy of the DNA code refers to the fact that either strand of the double-stranded DNA is theoretically enough to specify all the information in the genome. This is true because the two strands simply mirror one another - they're complementary.

If the other strand doesn't technically hold any additional information, why does the body persist with it? Chiefly, the complementary strand is useful to the check for, and correct, errors. (Having two copies of an important document is vastly preferably to having only one. If you spill coffee on one copy and can't make out some of the words, you can use the remaining copy to fill in the gaps.) There are probably also additional reasons for having two strands, such as keeping the information-carrying nitrogenous bases safely tucked away on the inside of the DNA molecule.

Thursday, 30 October 2008

What are heat shock proteins?

The story all started like this:

In 1962 someone at the Genetics Institute in Pavia, Italy, turned up the temperature in an incubator holding fruit flies. When Ferruccio Ritossa, then a young geneticist, examined the cells of these “heat shocked” flies, he noticed that their chromosomes had puffed up at discrete locations. The puffy appearance was a known sign that genes were being activated in those regions to give rise to their encoded proteins, so those sites of activity became known as the heat shock loci [and their proteins became known as heat shock proteins].

Since then, heat shock proteins have been discovered in almost all cellular life, and are among the oldest molecules to have been conserved by evolution. Despite their importance they are poorly, if understandably, named - which was why I quoted the above explanatory passage (found here) at the outset. A much better name for the class of proteins would be stress proteins, since they are apparently induced in increased numbers by a whole array of stressors, such as hypoxia, toxin exposure, ultraviolet light, infections, and (of course) heat. In fact, some researchers prefer to call the proteins by this very name.

The role of heat shock proteins becomes more clear if you consider some of the perils of protein formation. The genetic code of a protein (DNA and then RNA) only tells the assembly machinery which amino acid to slot in next. It doesn't - directly - tell the protein how to assume its unique and complicated 3D structure. Yet the right 3D structure is everything for a protein - it defines to a large extent what the protein is capable of.

So how do proteins get their 3D structures? Largely, it is the forces between the various amino acids, in multiple areas, that forces the chain to assume its particular knot-like shape. ('Knot-like' indeed: take a look at a relatively simple protein - G-actin.) For instance, if two amino acids repel each other (perhaps because of electrostatic forces), they will move further apart. The opposite holds for amino acids that attract one another. Furthermore, hydrophobic amino acids tend to 'want' to be in the centre of the protein, away from the water around it, whereas hydophilic amino acids 'want' the reverse.

By itself, this is often enough to construct the proteins' 3-dimentionality. But sometimes this isn't enough, and the protein needs extra help. Enter the 'heat shock proteins', which seem to act as 'chaperones' for developing proteins. They help the folding of the developing protein and assist in stabilising protein-to-protein interactions.

This explains why some heat shock proteins seem to be permanently expressed - they are always needed for certain proteins. On the other hand, it also provides a reason why their expression is vastly up-regulated under conditions of stress. As the author quoted above notes:

Under emergency conditions, such as extreme heat or cold, oxygen deprivation, dehydration or starvation, a cell would be struggling just to survive. Critical proteins might be degraded by the harsh environment, even as the cell would try to churn out replacements. In these circumstances, heat shock proteins would mitigate the stress by rescuing essential proteins, dismantling and recycling damaged ones, and generally keeping cell operations running as smoothly as possible. Hence, when a cell is under high stress, one of its first responses will be to manufacture more of the HSPs [heat shock proteins] themselves, as Ritossa first witnessed 46 years ago.

Finally, heat shock proteins seem to play an important role in immunity (binding to an antigen and helping its presentation to our immune cells) as well as a poorly identified role in the cardiovascular system. The area of heat shock proteins is undergoing heavy research and much intellectual upheaval, apparently, so expect to hear more about these guys in the near future.

Tuesday, 21 October 2008

Genetics: Penetrance

In genetics, penetrance refers to the proportion of individuals with a particular gene that express that gene phenotypically. Recall that an organism's phenotype is its physical properties, which are in part caused by its genes. So in other words, if 95% of all the people with the Huntington's gene go on to clinically develop Huntinton's disease, the gene can be said to have 95% penetrance.

I'm not convinced that penetrance is as watertight a concept as it should be. Take, for instance, phenylketonuria, an autosomal recessive disease characterised by mental retardation caused by an inability to metabolise the amino acid phenylalanine. Virtually every single child who is homozygous for this deleterious gene will go on to a lifetime of mental retardation and seizures if fed a normal diet. Yet, if it is fed a special diet that lacks this amino acid, the child will be symptom-free. So what is the penetrance in this case? 100% or 0%?

There are other problems with penetrance too, but it has entrenched itself as a useful tool (in abstraction at least) within the subject of genetics. It should not be confused with expressivity, which measures the degree of expression of a genetically-determined trait. Penetrance is used when the phenomenon is a digital all-or-nothing (i.e. you either have Huntington's disease or you don't; you can't 'half' have it).

Tuesday, 30 September 2008

What causes the acidosis in diabetic ketoacidosis?

Diabetic ketoacidosis (DKA) is one of the most feared acute complications of diabetes. It is basically a state characterised by hyperglycaemia and a metabolic acidosis with ketones present in the blood stream.

The bulk of the acid load comes from these ketones that are formed. Without even a bare minimum of workable insulin (as in Type 1 diabetes, or in rare cases of Type 2), fatty acids from our fat stores are liberated, sent to the liver, and used to create ketones. These ketones are all acids, and thus they lower the pH.

There is also renal hypoperfusion to account for. Hyperglycaemia osmotically draws water into the vascular bed from the cells, but it also causes water to be lost in the urine by the same method. This consistently high loss of water requires diabetics to maintain a higher-than-average input too. Failure to do so (especially if the ketones make the patient nauseous, or even cause him to vomit) causes intravascular depletion, which is fundamentally the first step in a DKA. This hypovolaemia causes the prerenal kidney dysfunction (which causes retention of the daily acid load) and a lactic acidosis from tissue hypoperfusion. Both of these factors contribute to generating an acidosis, although the ketones do make a larger contribution.

Sunday, 28 September 2008

How does end-stage cardiac failure predispose to hypoglycaemia?

As a follow-on to the previous post, I thought I'd just come back to the point about cardiac failure also predisposing to hypoglycaemia.

It isn't immediately clear why this should be, since the heart isn't directly involved in glucose homeostasis at all. The theory that I go with is that cardiac failure almost invariably involves congestion of the liver, as a result of a relative inability to pump blood onwards. The resultant backup of blood and interstitial fluid impairs the departure of blood from the liver. And, since the liver does the bulk of the body's gluconeogenesis and glycogenolysis, amongst the things that potentially reside in the blood leaving liver, of couse, is glucose.

How does end-stage renal failure cause hypoglycaemia?

It is true that one of the rarer causes of hypoglycaemia is end-stage renal failure. In this regard, the kidney joins the liver and the heart as being organs that can disrupt glucose homeostasis when severely hypofunctional (there are probably others too).

We've covered the liver here, but how about the kidney? What is often forgotten is that the kidney is, like the liver, a site of gluconeogenesis, albeit a more minor one. Together they produce a maximum of 20% of the body's total gluconeogenesis, but this process is stimulated by adrenaline (epinephrine) entirely, not glucagon, which suggests that the kidneys are ever more crucial in maintaining normal blood glucose levels in conditions of bodily stress (like exercise, hypoglycaemia, and infections).

The kidneys don't store glycogen - that's done almost exclusively in the liver and muscles - but their gluconeogenic role is enough to explain why end-stage renal failure can sometimes lead to hypoglycaemia. However, there is another aspect to consider, and that is that the kidneys are a site of insulin clearance. As with gluconeogenesis, their role here is dwarfed by the liver's but it is still significant. The resulting increased half-life of insulin in end-stage renal disease can potentially cause hypoglycaemia too. In practice, however, insulin secretion is usually well suppressed as you approach hypoglycaemia, so it isn't clear how much this component contributes to renal failure's hypoglycaemia. It certainly causes headaches with regulating diabetic patient's overall glucose levels in this situation though!

Friday, 26 September 2008

Clever, no?

If we eat a meal consisting mainly of carbohydrates, then insulin is the dominant hormone released, while glucagon is suppressed.  Insulin duly stimulates glucose uptake by peripheral cells, as well as glycogen synthesis in the liver and muscles.  In addition, hepatic gluconeogenesis and ketogenesis are inhibited by insulin, a process facilitated by the low levels of glucagon.  Lastly, fat storage occurs in adipose tissue.

On the other hand, if we eat a meal consisting mainly of protein, both insulin and glucagon are raised.  The reason that insulin levels are boosted
 is that the hormone stimulates amino acid uptake and protein synthesis.  In other words, the hormone is anabolic with regards to protein, which makes sense, as the right time to increase protein production is surely when you've just taken in a whole lot of amino acids!  However, without enough carbohydrates in our hypothetical meal, there is the very real risk of insulin causing hypoglycaemia.  To counteract this risk, glucagon is also secreted, which causes a stimulation of hepatic gluconeogenesis.  This balances the opposing glucose-lowering effects of insulin, thereby preventing hypoglycaemia.

Thursday, 21 August 2008

Antioxidant supplements - in practice

In the last post on this topic, we saw that there are tentative theoretical reasons for why it might be worthwhile augmenting our natural stores of antioxidants with supplements (pharmacological or natural, like fruits). As I emphasised there, by itself, this is not enough. We have to go and do the experiments and find out the truth of the matter.

Of course, there are experiments and then there are experiments. One all the varieties of study methodologies, the one most prone to misinterpretation by the press and public are the observational studies. Let's say we want to see if antioxidants have any effect on cancer prevention. Since vegetables are a good source of antioxidants, we can go and collect two large groups of people - those who eat lots of vegetables and those who almost never eat vegetables. We then collect data on the incidences of various cancers from each group and compare them.

Now let's say that the veggie-guzzling group showed a statistically significant reduction in the number of cancers that developed. Hooray for antioxidants, we may be tempted to say - they seem to reduce cancer!

But this would be a gross misreading of the experiment, although a very common one. The problem with observational studies is that the two groups already exist, and are simply picked by the researcher. Seeing as they already exist, they are not randomly generated, and thus prone to hidden statistical bias. For instance, the above result is certainly compatible with the theory that antioxidants reduce cancer, but it is also compatible with the theory that:
  • Some other substance(s) in vegetables, and not antioxidants, reduces cancer.
  • The people who tended to eat more vegetables also tended to smoke less, and so developed less lung cancer.
  • The people who tended to eat more vegetables also tended to exercise more, and thus showed reduced cancer rates.
  • The people who tended to eat more vegetables also tended to be wealthier, and could thus afford regular cancer surveillance screenings, thus lowering their incidence of cancer.

Apart from the first option, you can see that the observational studies are perpetually vulnerable to perfectly valid objections of the type "The people who tended to eat more vegetables also tended to [X], and it was actually [X] that reduced the cancer rates, not the antioxidants in vegetables." In other words, it is almost impossible to separate a correlation (which observational studies show very nicely) from a cause (which is really what we need to know about).

Discussing the pitfalls of observational studies is necessary, because there are many examples of such observational studies that show that antioxidant intake (usually in the form of vegetables and fruits, but sometimes in the form of artificial supplements) correlates with healthier outcomes (e.g. lower cancer rates, lower rates of macular degeneration, lower rates of strokes and heart attacks, etc.). Whilst these studies did show the need for further research, by themselves they are not convincing.

For the convincing study types, we must turn to randomised control trials (RCT), the gold standard of studies. In this setup, two groups are selected from a population at random. In this way, they should have the same number of fruit eaters, the same number of smokers, the same number of doctors, the same number of gamblers, etc., etc.. Only once we have the two groups do we introduce the variable that we wish to test for; in other words, antioxidants are then given to one group, and another substance, usually a placebo, is given to the other.

For good measure, the RCTs are usually double-blinded if possible - neither the patients nor the people administering the antioxidants know whether a particular person is getting the antioxidant or the placebo. This is to ensure that no subtle psychological factors play themselves out here. (For instance, a patient who knows he's getting the placebo may opt to eat more healthily to compensate.)

Although RCTs do have their down side, it should be clear that they are much more accurate in determining whether antioxidants cause better health outcomes, rather than are simply correlated with them.

And so, I can now reveal the results to you... (drum roll, please)...

With very few exceptions, properly designed randomised control trials have failed to show a benefit from antioxidant supplementation. In other words, antioxidants don't appear to be of benefit at present.

To give you some idea of the research, I looked at the four most prestigious medical journals - the Lancet, the Journal of the American Medical Association, the British Journal of Medicine, and the New England Journal of Medicine for recent research on this topic. Since these journals usually only accept the best designed trials, they are the most reliable. Here is a sampling:

  • This study showed that "Vitamin E had no benefit in patients with mild cognitive impairment".
  • This study concluded that "There is insufficient evidence to support the role of dietary antioxidants, including the use of dietary antioxidant supplements, for the primary prevention of early AMD [age-related macular degeneration]".
  • This study "provides no evidence to support the use of antioxidant or folinic acid supplements in children with Down’s syndrome."
  • This study found that "in patients at high risk for cardiovascular events, treatment with vitamin E for a mean of 4.5 years has no apparent effect on cardiovascular outcomes."
  • This study's authors believe that the use of antioxidant vitamins in the setting of patients with coronary disease and low HDL levels "must be questioned".
  • The results of this study "[did] not support the hypothesis that depletion of vitamin E, selenium, cysteine, or riboflavin has a role in the development of kwashiorkor."
  • This recent study ended off by stating that, "In this large, long-term trial of male physicians, neither vitamin E nor vitamin C supplementation reduced the risk of major cardiovascular events. These data provide no support for the use of these supplements for the prevention of cardiovascular disease in middle-aged and older men."
  • This metanalysis concluded, on the basis of several well-designed randomised control trials that vitamin E had no beneficial effect cardiovascular disease, and that beta carotene [a vitamin A derivative] led to a slightly increased risk of cardiovascular death.
  • This metanalysis looked at the effects of common antioxidant supplements on mortality in several diseases, and showed that "treatment with beta carotene, vitamin A, and vitamin E may increase mortality." [bold type added]

Of course, there are dissenting results in the midst of this, but they are at present hugely out-numbered by the RCTs that demonstrate either no benefit (usually) or increased risk (rarely). The latter is particularly disturbing, as it suggests that even the old assumption on antioxidants ("they may not work, but at least they aren't harmful") may be wrong.

I must stress that the above is not some strict and comprehensive review of the literature - it is meant for interested laymen. The realities are more complex and subtle. However, I think that the research may accurately be summarised thus:

Although there are both some theoretical reasons and several observational studies that indicate that antioxidants may be protective against several diseases, the randomised control trials have not, on the whole, backed this up. Most of them have failed to show an improvement in mortality rates. At present - and this may change as new evidence comes in! - there is no strong evidence to suggest that supplemented antioxidants are routinely beneficial.

Furthermore, on present evidence, we can conclusively say that popular "complementary" health adverts that claim extravagant benefits for antioxidants are simply wrong. And attempting to back up your claims by alluding to one or two observational studies from 20 years ago, whilst ignoring the succeeding RCTs on the same topic, is frankly dishonest. At best you can say that the evidence is equivocal - you certainly can't pretend that the research unanimously shows that, say, antioxidants prevent cancers and skin aging.

This rather startling conclusion generates a paradox: if supplemented antioxidants are unhelpful, why would the body be apparently going to such lengths to have its own precious antioxidant systems? I'm not sure of the answer, but there are a few options:

  • Option 1: The body is already at its optimal free radical/antioxidant balance (remember: free radicals are beneficial in selected instances), and any additional antioxidants don't result in additional benefits.
  • Option 2: The body thinks it is at its optimal free radical/antioxidant balance, based on what was best for most of our evolutionary past, though not what is best for us today - and thus it fails to absorb or utilise any other supplemented antioxidants we may feed it.
  • Option 3: The administered antioxidants are too blunt an instrument for the body to derive benefit from. For instance, it would be nice to have elevated antioxidant levels in the brain (where it may protect against Alzheimer's disease) but it might not be a good idea to have these elevated levels in neutrophils (which require free radicals to destroy the bacteria). Thus consuming extra antioxidants results is both positive and negative effects, which usually cancel each other out.

There may be other plausible explanations too - feel free to add them in the comments section if you wish!

Tuesday, 19 August 2008

Antioxidant supplements - in theory

From the preceding posts, it should be clear that free radicals generally cause deleterious effects, although there are a minority of beneficial ones too. The previous post has also highlighted the fact that the body has several antioxidant systems in place to counter the potential damage.

Sometimes the body will even go to dangerous lengths to boost its innate antioxidant capacities, and if you'll permit me a brief digression, I'll mention two candidates. Take the example of uric acid, the final breakdown product of purine (i.e. adenine and guanine) metabolism. Most mammals can break down uric acid further, but we humans have lost this ability. This could simply be an evolutionary error, of course, but there is another possibility. It turns out that uric acid is a very good antioxidant, and some researchers hypothesise that we have lost the ability to break it down on purpose so that the body's antioxidant systems are thereby boosted. The downside of our abnormally high uric acid levels is that in some people the substance is deposited in joints and tendons, provoking an inflammatory response: namely, gout.

This example doesn't stand alone. There are schools of thought that claim a similar rationale behind the high levels of bilirubin in neonates - bilirubin is a very good antioxidant too, and neonates need good antioxidants as they make the transition to a life of high oxygen concentration outside the uterus. Of course, in a few cases the hyperbilirubinaemia can cause the neonate to develop kernicterus, but this might be a price evolution is willing to pay for all those other babies that are saved oxidative damage to their tissues.

And so on. Even if the above two interesting but contentious hypotheses turn out to be wrong, the fact still remains that the body undeniably works to reduce free radicals in the majority of instances. So, since the body seems quite keen on its own antioxidant systems, it seems intuitively likely that taking additional antioxidants as supplements might be beneficial. On the face of it, those annoying adverts boasting the strong antioxidant effects of product X might have a kernel of truth about them.

Of course, shrewd reasoning and clever hypotheses aren't enough - we must look at what the actual data says. That'll be the topic of the next post.

Monday, 18 August 2008

How does the body protect itself against free radicals?

Seeing that free radicals have posed a danger since the beginnings of evolutionary time, it isn't surprising that the body has engineered several systems that aim to counter this assault. And they are quite ingenious.

Prevention is better than cure, as the old adage goes, and the body has taken this to heart. Recall that transition metals like iron and copper are capable of donating or accepting free electrons during intracellular reactions - and are thus able to generate free radicals. To obviate this, the most obvious option is to simply eliminate these transition metals altogether, but the problem with this idea is that these substances are absolutely vital to the formation of several crucial substances (like haemoglobin!). Instead, the body chooses the more moderate and sensible option or keeping the metals bound in an inactive state to proteins until the exact time when they are needed. For instance, iron is transported around the blood complexed with transferrin and when it is stored it is first bound up with ferritin.

Antioxidants are another of the body's tricks to ameliorate the potentially pernicious effects of free radicals. An antioxidant is any substance that prevents the formation of free radicals, or inactivates them once they are formed. The more important ones are vitamin A, vitamin C, vitamin E and glutathione. For instance, vitamin E is often found embedded in the cell membrane, and it is perfectly suited in this position to prevent the lipid peroxidation chain reaction that we mentioned in this post.

The last set of defences against free radicals are a set of enzymes that act as free radical scavengers. The prominent examples of these are:
  • Superoxide dismutases, which convert superoxide to H2O2.
  • Catalases, which decompose H2O2 to form oxygen and water.
  • Glutathione peroxidase, the most important peroxidase, also catalyses the 'detoxification' of H2O2.

Actually, there are several catalases and perioxidases, and the general scheme looks something like this:

The above constitute the body's innate antioxidant mechanisms. An increase in free radicals, or a decrease in antioxidant functioning, creates an imbalance of the two forces in the free radicals' favour, a condition known as oxidative stress.

Main source: Robbins Pathologic Basis of Disease; 6th edn., Cotran, Kumar, Collins

Saturday, 16 August 2008

What are the biological functions of free radicals?

The reactivity of free radicals has the potential to cause major problems for the body, as we've just seen. However, on occassion these potent customers can be put to more productive uses, of which there are two main categories.

1. Killing of microorganisms

It is one thing for phagocytes (like neutrophils and macrophages) to ingest a foreign organism, but the problem still remains to kill them. Usually, a cocktail of substances is thrown at the poor swallowed microorganisms. Some of these substances are specific enzymes that targeting a known weak spot in the organism's defences. However, a large portion of the cocktail is simply non-specific reactive oxygen species, which consist of free radicals derived from oxygen. In this way, the damage of free radicals can be unleashed on a foreign body.

Let's look at one specific example in a little more detail. Say a neutrophil phagocytoses a bacterium so that the bacterium is now within the cell imprisoned in a vacuole called a phagosome. Immediately, a particular enzyme grabs hold of oxygen and converts it into a substance with the awesome name of superoxide (O2-). As the formula shows, this compound is a free radical, and it is capable of wreaking the appropriate amount of havoc. On the way to being neutralised by the body (you can't leave it going for long!), it cycles through a number of damaging intermediates, like hydrogen peroxide (H2O2) and hypochlorous acid (HOCl, 'chlorine bleach'), which also contribute to damaging and killing the bacterium.


2. Cellular signalling
The experts are divided on how extensive the role is for free radical cellular signalling. Certainly, nitrous oxide (NO) is both a free radical and is capable of an enormous amount of effects on things like vascular tone, cytokine production, neurotransmission and even penile erections.

Things become a little murkier when we move away from this particular example, though. Free radical damage can certainly induce apoptosis or necrosis, but this is unlikely to be a designed effect of the free radicals. For instance, it makes more sense to view any induced apoptosis as being part of the body's 'disaster management plan' when presented with catastrophically damaged cells.

There are arguments both for and against free radicals being extensively used by the body for signalling purposes, but I don't have the expertise to judge them in the depth they deserve, I'm afraid. Anyway, it should be enough for our purposes to simply have heard of the topic. :)